PeopleSaturday

What happened to Makhno after the defeat of Wrangel 

We talk about how the Bolsheviks dishonestly acted with the Ukrainian anarchists and Makhno.
The choice of two evils
Makhno did not love the communists before the October Revolution. Like any consistent anarchist, he was skeptical about the very idea of ​​political parties that were leading a “dirty card game for power”. But the left flank — the Social Revolutionaries , the Mensheviks, the Bolsheviks, saw Makhno as forced allies.
After October, the Ukrainian Bolsheviks began arresting their opponents from the left flank. Makhno resisted this Bolshevik repression, and together with the remaining Left Socialist-Revolutionaries went into opposition. Probably, if this conflict had developed, Makhno would have realized everything even then – but the Gulyaypole workers’ self-government would have far more serious problems. In early 1918, the troops of the Ukrainian State, supported by the German and Austrian occupiers, occupied Yekaterinoslavl (the Dnieper, formerly known as Dnepropetrovsk). Makhno’s troops retreated to Taganrog, while he himself went to Moscow to ask the Soviet government for help in fighting the occupiers.
There he was warmly welcomed by V. Lenin and J. Sverdlov. You can understand it – the situation is desperate, the Germans and Ukrainian nationalists are in charge of its homeland, and Red Moscow is ready to provide all possible assistance. Makhno chooses the lesser evil: no matter how bad he treats the violent methods of the Bolsheviks, yet alliance with them was more acceptable to him than with the nationalists whom he hated with all his soul.
Fight together
In the summer of 1918, Makhno arrived in Kharkov and formed a partisan detachment. His struggle is phenomenally successful – he soon manages to put together a decent army from the partisans of southern Ukraine, whose forces manage to liberate his native Gulyaypole and the environs by the end of the year.
But these were only tactical successes. At the beginning of 1919, Anton Denikin launched an offensive in the Donbass , and a new owner, Hetman Petliura, who also wants to regain the southern lands, sets in Kiev. Makhno needs help, so on February 12, 1919, at the Congress of Councils of the Gulyaypolsky District, he says these words:
“If the Bolshevik comrades go from Great Russia to Ukraine to help us in a difficult struggle against counter-revolution, we must tell them:“ Welcome, dear friends! ”If they come here to monopolize Ukraine, we will tell them:“ Hands off! ”
So it happened. In February, Makhno signed an agreement with the Ukrainian Red Army that his unit would join the 1st Ukrainian Front, and the territories under the rule of Makhno would become part of the RSFSR on the rights of autonomy. Makhno and the  Communists helped each other repel the attacks of both Denikinians and Petliurists.
But Makhno seemed to be aware that the Bolsheviks wanted to destroy the freemen. Therefore, after the first successful joint hostilities, he became arguing with the Reds, did not execute their orders and at the same time strengthened freemen. He did not allow the establishment of Soviet power in the territories under his control, trying, wherever possible, to defend the anarchist principles of the structure of life, not allowing them to be replaced by the “proletarian dictatorship.” In the summer of 1919, all this came to the direct attacks of anarchist units on the Red Army units.
Betrayal
As early as June 6, Leon Trotsky, with his order, abolished the autonomy with the Makhnovka freemen, but in fact the Soviet troops and the Makhnovists continued their tactical cooperation. On September 1, Makhno finally announced the creation of his own Revolutionary Insurgent Army and a peasant Anarchist Republic, in which there is no place for the dictatorship of the proletariat, and the main organizational body is a free, self-governing council.
Soon a new white force emerged in the south of Russia – the army of Peter Wrangel . The communists, for whom Makhno was already outlawed, were forced to again ask for help from the free army. Makhno perfectly understood why the Bolsheviks needed him. But in him, apparently, there was a hope that by defeating Wrangel, he would be able to defeat the Reds, just as he had already defeated the Germans, Deninkinites, and the Ukrainian state powers. In addition, he saw that the Ukrainian peasants and workers loved him, but did not favor the Bolsheviks.
In the fall of 1920, after one of the battles with Wrangel won by the left alliance, the Bolsheviks simply surrounded the 2.5 thousandth detachment of the Makhnovists and began methodically shooting machine guns at those with whom they had just fought side by side. And in early 1921, the Bolsheviks organized a real military operation against the Gulyaypole Republic. Simple soldiers, many of whom knew and respected Makhno (he was always close and understandable to the common people), genuinely wondered why all this was necessary, and fought reluctantly. But they fought because the commissioners were behind them. At that moment, Makhno had nothing to oppose to the repeatedly increased power of the Communists, so he fled abroad.

Show More

Related Articles

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Back to top button
Close
Close